Fixing Digital Funding in the NSW Government

Digital funding was broken Digital services are central to modern government, but annual budgets and rigid funding rules make it difficult to adapt as services evolve. In 2018, I’d been blogging about some of the…

Digital funding was broken

Digital services are central to modern government, but annual budgets and rigid funding rules make it difficult to adapt as services evolve.

In 2018, I’d been blogging about some of the challenges with investment in government digital services:

I joined the NSW Department of Customer Service to help reform how government funds digital services. Over four years, the work included:

This case study reviews my experiences helping DCS reform digital funding to achieve outcomes that better meet citizens’ needs.

Stimulating growth

In 2019, the NSW government established the Digital Restart Fund (DRF) to enhance government services through technology. The fund aimed to address issues related to legacy technologies, changing public needs, and a lack of flexibility in funding and governance models. To achieve this, the new funding model in NSW made three critical changes:

  • Incremental Funding: Funding was released in smaller increments based on progress towards specific outcomes, promoting agile behaviour and reducing risk.
  • Persistent Teams: Funding shifted from multi-year projects to supporting persistent teams that delivered end-to-end customer journeys, ensuring continuity and expertise.
  • Outcome-Focused Governance: Ministerial-level committees governed the fund, demanding demonstrable progress towards improved customer outcomes before releasing new funding.

The NSW government witnessed rapid growth in the fund, and the relatively  small initial budget of $50 million per year was expanded to $2.1 billion over four years.

Universal challenges with funding

Traditional funding models are poorly suited to digital work. They commit too much too early, divide investment along agency boundaries and leave little room to learn or adapt as delivery progresses.

Critical Challenges in Traditional Funding Models:

  • Governance and funding do not support digital delivery: Traditional funding decisions are often made before an initiative starts, leading to a lack of financial scrutiny during the project and hindering cost-saving innovations.
  • Siloed funding inhibits collaboration: Cross-agency initiatives require collaboration, but traditional funding models often follow organisational boundaries, preventing effective cooperation.
  • Risk-averse funding inhibits experimentation: Traditional funding processes discourage experimentation, reducing the potential for innovation and adaptation.
  • Funding models are ill-suited to a changing environment: Rapidly evolving digital services require flexibility, which is lacking in traditional stage-gated funding and project management practices.

Reforming funding

To improve digital funding and encourage agile practices, we developed a series of principles to guide our work:

  • Fund less, but fund more often: Implement smaller, frequent funding releases to align with digital delivery rhythms and support innovative work without long budget cycles.
  • Announce more achievements and fewer intentions: Focus on delivering features and functionality that benefit citizens instead of making big spending commitments without concrete outcomes.
  • Regularly review every part of the budget: Adopt a model that scrutinises project funding and business-as-usual funding, allowing for strategic reprioritization of funds.
  • Fund persistent, mission-centred, multidisciplinary teams: Provide sustainable funding to support the permanence and effectiveness of teams, encouraging successful and experienced delivery.
  • Build modern governance and management practices: Develop a governance model that empowers teams, encourages experimentation, and supports evidence-based decision-making.
  • Encourage emerging and experimental practices: Create a balanced portfolio to spread risk and foster digital innovation, recognizing that some experiments may yield high returns.
  • Embrace cloud technology and a little opex over a lot of capex: Shift from capital expenditure to operational expenditure to support scalable, configurable solutions.

Conclusion

Digital funding reform helped NSW support more adaptive delivery and investment in services. The experience reinforced the value of funding against progress and outcomes, rather than treating an initial business case as a fixed plan.

I left DCS in 2022. In just its third year, DRF had allocated $687 million in funding to 107 digital and ICT projects.

Collaboration between digital and financial professionals is crucial to simplify approvals processes and enable digital transformation. Governments must boldly and openly adopt these reforms to become effective and trusted institutions in the eyes of citizens.